Mouse Guard: Fall 1152 (quick review)
Mouse Guard: Fall 1152
[Amazon][I got mine from Comic Quest]
The official description:
Mouse Guard is comic book written and illustrated by David Petersen. Each mini-series is six issues long and published by Archaia Studios Press as well as a collected hardcover edition [sic]. Villard will be publishing the softcover edition of Mouse Guard Fall 1152 in 2008.
In the world of Mouse Guard, mice struggle to live safely and prosper amongst harsh conditions and a host of predators. Thus the Mouse Guard was formed: more than just soldiers that fight off intruders, they are guides for common mice looking to journey without confrontation from one hidden village to another. The Guard patrol borders, find safeways and paths through dangerous territories and treacherous terrain, watch weather patterns, and keep the mouse territories free of predatory infestation. They do so with fearless dedication so that they might not just exist, but truly live. Saxon, Kenzie and Lieam, three such Guardsmice, are dispatched to find a missing merchant mouse that never arrived at his destination. Their search for the missing mouse reveals much more than they expect, as they stumble across a traitor in the Guard’s own ranks.
- “Mouse Guard: Fall 1152″ is about…
… mice living like people in a medieval setting. Aside from this, everything else is so-far realistic (their “monsters” are wolves, snakes, etc. No fictional monsters).
- This review is based on…
… reading the collected paperback.
- My background stuff on this is/are..
… comics. I first got wind of it when I ran into a news item regarding RPG being developed based on the comic. The title “Mouse Guard”, plus the nicely drawn image of 3 mice that looked like RPG characters piqued my interest (that’s basically the pic on the left).
- It’s similar to…
… nothing I’ve previously seen.
- It reminds me of…
… a mature kid’s book. The plot, though not overly simplistic, is not overly complex. However, people, or rather mice, die here, folks.
- The aesthetics are…
… cool! I loved the art!
- The cool thing/s is/are...
… the art! It’s what got me interested in the first place.
… the characters. The art and the way the characters behave in given situations shows a lot of personality (if not depth).
… there are no humans! I didn’t want a Stewart Little, and I didn’t get it! No mouse/human interaction. In fact, there appears to be no humans in their world at all!
- I didn’t quite like…
… that there was no magic. I was expecting LOTR in a mouse world setting, which I erroneously assumed to include magic. There was none.
… that the main villain’s motivation didn’t feel well developed.
… that most of the characters, though well characterized, seem thinly developed. It may be too much to ask for, though, since this is the first in a somewhat action oriented comic series.
… the fact that it was too short!
- Overall…
… I like it! It’s a bit on the short and shallow side, but it has charm and personality, so like it. I hope that the motivations for each character gets deeper as the series progresses. I’m looking forward to the next mini-series.
- My final recommendation on Mouse Guard: Fall 1152 is…
… get it if you like the art.
… get it if you want a simple story in that setting with a twist.
… don’t get it if you’re expecting heavy magic or a human/animal relationship type story.
- Don’t forget…
… it has medieval mice with non-fictional “monsters”!

















